Kensington Sales Group
Comparison

Cooperative contracts head to head: which co-op should you pursue?

The co-op matchups vendors ask about most, side by side: who buys, how you get on, what it costs and when each one is the better choice.

Updated November 15, 2026 · By Mike Dombo, Kensington Sales Group · 9 min read

Four matchups vendors ask about most. Each compares who buys, how vendors get on, fees, terms and solicitation cadence, then says when each co-op is the better pick. For every co-op side by side, see cooperative contracts compared.

Sourcewell vs OMNIA Partners

The short answer: Sourcewell is usually easier to win and strongest for equipment, vehicles and products sold through dealers to local government. OMNIA is harder to win but worth more per award, and strongest for facilities, supplies, furniture and services.

SourcewellOMNIA Partners
Who buysGovernment, tribal, K-12, higher ed and nonprofit entities; 50,000+ members in the US and CanadaState and local government, K-12, higher ed and nonprofits (plus private-sector members)
How vendors get onSourcewell runs its own national RFP and awards several suppliers per categoryA lead public agency runs the RFP with national-use language; you respond to that agency
Admin feeVendor proposes it in its response; commonly 1–2% of salesSet in each lead-agency agreement; commonly 1–3%
Contract term4 years plus up to three 1-year extensionsFollows the lead agency contract, often 3–5 years
Solicitation cadenceEach category roughly every 4 yearsVaries by category and lead agency

Choose Sourcewell if…

  • You sell equipment, vehicles or products through a national dealer network.
  • Your buyers are cities, counties, special districts and schools across many states.
  • You want to propose your own fee and compete with several other awardees.

Choose OMNIA Partners if…

  • You can commit to aggressive national pricing and joint marketing with OMNIA staff.
  • You sell facilities services, supplies, furniture or IT, where OMNIA’s portfolio is deepest.
  • You want a single-award contract that sets you apart from competitors.

Sourcewell vs NASPO ValuePoint

If your buyers are cities, counties and schools, Sourcewell usually comes first. If your buyers are state agencies, NASPO ValuePoint matters more, but each state must sign an addendum before anyone in it can buy.

SourcewellNASPO ValuePoint
Who buysGovernment, tribal, K-12, higher ed and nonprofit entities; 50,000+ members in the US and CanadaState agencies first; local governments where the state’s participating addendum allows
How vendors get onSourcewell runs its own national RFP and awards several suppliers per categoryA lead state and multistate sourcing team run the RFP; each state then signs a participating addendum
Admin feeVendor proposes it in its response; commonly 1–2% of sales0.25% to NASPO ValuePoint, plus any fee a participating state adds
Contract term4 years plus up to three 1-year extensionsPortfolios commonly run about 5 years
Solicitation cadenceEach category roughly every 4 yearsEach portfolio about every 5 years; no mid-term adds

Choose Sourcewell if…

  • Most of your buyers are local governments, schools or special districts.
  • You want one contract that works in every state without separate addenda.

Choose NASPO ValuePoint if…

  • Your core buyers are state agencies, or your category runs through state IT and supply contracts.
  • You can negotiate participating addenda state by state and carry the lowest co-op fee into a five-year price.

TIPS vs BuyBoard

Both are worth holding if Texas schools and local governments are important to you. TIPS solicits more often and sets fees per solicitation; BuyBoard charges a flat 2% per purchase order and is a habit for many Texas districts.

TIPSBuyBoard
Who buysSchools, colleges, cities, counties, state agencies and eligible nonprofits nationwideTexas local governments and schools (Texas program) and agencies in other states (national program)
How vendors get onRegion 8 ESC runs frequent category solicitations and awards many vendorsRespond to a numbered proposal invitation; awarded line items become sellable
Admin feeSet per solicitation, usually 1–2% of sales2% service fee per purchase order; $400 per vehicle purchase order
Contract termAbout 3 years plus up to three 1-year renewalsShort initial terms with renewals
Solicitation cadenceMany solicitations a yearSeveral proposal invitations a year

Choose TIPS if…

  • You want frequent solicitation windows and a fee that may be 1% in your category.
  • You sell construction, JOC or energy services, where TIPS is strong.

Choose BuyBoard if…

  • Your buyers are Texas school districts and cities that default to BuyBoard.
  • You sell vehicles and prefer a flat $400 fee per purchase order.

Sourcewell vs HGACBuy

Most vehicle and equipment manufacturers hold both. Sourcewell has the broader buyer base; HGACBuy is the habit for fire, EMS and many public works buyers, and its buyer-paid vehicle charge changes the price math.

SourcewellHGACBuy
Who buysGovernment, tribal, K-12, higher ed and nonprofit entities; 50,000+ members in the US and CanadaLocal governments, state agencies and qualifying nonprofits that sign an interlocal contract
How vendors get onSourcewell runs its own national RFP and awards several suppliers per categoryRespond to an HGACBuy bid or proposal; awards go to the H-GAC board
Admin feeVendor proposes it in its response; commonly 1–2% of salesOrder Processing Charge built into contract pricing (paid by the buyer on motor vehicles)
Contract term4 years plus up to three 1-year extensionsFour years under current rules (older contracts ran 2–3 years)
Solicitation cadenceEach category roughly every 4 yearsEach category about every 4 years

Choose Sourcewell if…

  • You want the widest reach across local government and schools.
  • You prefer a simple vendor-paid percentage fee.

Choose HGACBuy if…

  • You sell fire apparatus, ambulances, emergency vehicles or 911 equipment.
  • Your buyers are used to HGACBuy order confirmations and configurable pricing.

Should you be on both?

Many established vendors hold both co-ops in a pair, because buyers have strong habits and won't switch co-ops to buy from you. Start with whichever your buyers cite most in recent purchases, then add the second when a solicitation opens. Our co-op selection guide has a scorecard.

Sources

Checked November 14, 2026. Fees, terms and eligibility change with each solicitation, so confirm the details in the current solicitation before you bid.

Found a broken link or something inaccurate? We keep this page up to date. If a link doesn't work or any information here is wrong or out of date, report it by email to research@kensingtonsalesgroup.com and we'll fix it.
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is Sourcewell or OMNIA Partners bigger?
OMNIA cites more than 600,000 member organizations across public and private sectors. Sourcewell reports more than 50,000 public and nonprofit members. For public buyers, both are national.
Is NASPO ValuePoint cheaper than Sourcewell?
Its own fee is lower: 0.25% versus the 1% to 2% most Sourcewell vendors propose. But states may add their own fee in their participating addenda.
Who runs TIPS and BuyBoard?
TIPS is run by the Region 8 Education Service Center in Pittsburg, Texas. BuyBoard is run by the Texas Association of School Boards in Austin.
Who pays the fee on HGACBuy vehicle purchases?
The buyer. HGACBuy’s Order Processing Charge appears on motor vehicle quotes and is paid by the customer. For most other products it is built into contract pricing.
Work with KSG

Turn this research into booked meetings.

Kensington Sales Group embeds SDRs who already know how agencies and utilities buy. See all services.

Government lead generation & appointment setting

Phone-led outreach to federal, SLED and utility decision-makers, with qualified meetings booked straight onto your calendar.

B2G lead generation

Embedded SDR teams

Trained reps prospect under your brand and keep deals moving, without the cost of hiring, training and managing your own team.

Outsourced SDR teams

Market intelligence

Research and direct conversations with buyers that show what your target agencies are planning, budgeting and buying next.

Market intelligence

Ready to build your public-sector pipeline?

Book a 30-minute call. We'll talk through your market, your ideal buyers and whether an embedded sales development team is the right fit — no commitment.